Connect with us

Insights

Apple Watch calorie counts far less accurate than heart rate or step tracking, review finds

Published

on

Apple Watches and similar wearable devices exhibit significant inaccuracies when estimating calories burned, despite performing well in monitoring heart rate and counting steps.

A comprehensive review of 56 studies conducted by researchers at the University of Mississippi found that while fitness trackers are generally reliable for basic metrics, they struggle with energy expenditure calculations—a key feature many users rely on for weight management and fitness goals.

The analysis revealed that Apple Watches had a mean absolute percentage error of 4.43% for heart rate monitoring and 8.17% for step counts. However, the error rate for energy expenditure calculations rose sharply to 27.96%.

The inaccuracy in calorie tracking was consistent across all types of users and activities tested, including walking, running, cycling, and mixed-intensity workouts, suggesting the problem is not limited to specific use cases or user groups.

Professor Minsoo Kang, who specialises in sport analytics, and doctoral student Ju-Pil Choe conducted the meta-analysis to evaluate how device accuracy varied across different user demographics, health conditions, Apple Watch versions, and types of physical activity.

Data from the National Institutes of Health indicates that wearable technology has become increasingly popular across all demographics, from elite athletes to sedentary individuals. As early as 2015, approximately one in eight Americans reported using a wearable activity monitor. By 2019, wearable technology had become the leading fitness trend, with the market continuing to expand.

“If people are using them to make decisions about their workouts or even medical conditions, the data should be accurate,” Choe said. “If the numbers are off, it could lead to confusion, overtraining or even miss health warnings.”

The findings suggest that while Apple Watches can serve as useful support tools—such as for tracking basic activity levels during recovery from surgery—they should not replace clinical monitoring equipment or medical judgement.

These devices are great for keeping track of habits and staying motivated,” Kang said. “But do not take every number as 100% truth, especially the calories.

“Think of it as a helpful guide, not a diagnostic tool. It is useful but not perfect.”

The researchers noted that newer Apple Watch models appeared to demonstrate improved accuracy compared to earlier versions, suggesting ongoing technological refinements.

“While we cannot say every update is a big leap forward, there is a noticeable trend of gradual improvements over time,” Choe said. “It shows that Apple is refining the technology over time.”

The study’s implications extend beyond consumer awareness to potential improvements in wearable technology development. Kang explained that identifying specific weaknesses could help manufacturers enhance their products.

“By showing where the weaknesses are, we can help developers get real feedback,” he said. “If they know what needs to be fixed, they can design better sensors or algorithms.

Our findings can guide improvements and help make these devices more useful for both everyday users and health care providers.”

The research highlights the importance of understanding the limitations of consumer health technology, particularly as these devices become increasingly integrated into both personal fitness routines and healthcare monitoring systems.

For older adults and those managing chronic conditions who may rely heavily on wearable devices for health tracking, the findings underscore the need to view such technology as supplementary rather than definitive health monitoring tools.

News

Finding could help identify diabetes patients at risk of vascular damage

Published

on

The longer someone has type 2 diabetes, the higher their cardiovascular disease risk, and changes in red blood cells may help explain it, new research suggests.

The study found red blood cells from patients with long-term diabetes harmed blood vessel function, while no such effect was seen in those newly diagnosed.

After seven years of follow-up, the blood cells of people initially diagnosed had developed the same harmful properties.

Zhichao Zhou, associate professor at Karolinska Institutet and lead author, said: “What really stands out in our study is that it is not only the presence of type 2 diabetes that matters, but how long you have had the disease.

“It is only after several years that red blood cells develop a harmful effect on blood vessels.”

Researchers at Karolinska Institutet in Sweden studied animals and patients with type 2 diabetes.

They identified microRNA-210, a small RNA that helps regulate gene activity, as a possible early biomarker of cardiovascular risk.

When its levels were restored in red blood cells, blood vessel function improved.

Eftychia Kontidou, doctoral student and first author, said: “If we can identify which patients are at greatest risk before vascular damage has already occurred, we can also become better at preventing complications.”

The researchers are now investigating whether the biomarker can be used in larger population studies.

Continue Reading

Insights

Global longevity initiative launches North American chapter

Published

on

The Global Initiative on Ageing and Longevity has launched a North American chapter to boost innovation and economic transformation in the longevity sector.

The organisation, known as GIA-L, said the new chapter will strengthen its mission to help people of all ages thrive across longer, healthier lives and tap into the growing longevity economy.

Building on its work with United Nations agencies and global partners, GIA-L said the US chapter will enhance its ability to advance initiatives at national and international levels.

Dr Alison Bryant has been appointed as the inaugural chair.

She currently serves as chief operating officer of the Learning Economy Foundation, a global non-profit developing digital infrastructure to transform education, skills and economic opportunity. Her previous roles include positions at Sesame Workshop and AARP.

Dr Bryant said: “We have a tremendous opportunity to strengthen public-private partnerships that improve life and learning across the age span.”

“This is the moment to reimagine how societies support people at every stage of life by aligning innovation, collaboration, and practical action that benefits all generations.”

Luis Gallegos, president of GIA Longevity, said: “Dr Bryant represents the leadership, strategic insight, and commitment to innovation that GIA Longevity calls for as we enter a new chapter of growth.”

GIA-L works with organisations to co-create products, services and models designed for a longevity-driven economy.

Continue Reading

News

UK bans junk food ads before 9pm to protect child health

Published

on

The UK has banned junk food adverts on TV before 9pm and online at all times to tackle childhood obesity.

The rules are expected to remove up to 7.2bn calories from children’s diets each year, reduce the number of children living with obesity by 20,000 and deliver around £2bn in health benefits over time.

Evidence shows advertising shapes what and when children eat, forming preferences from a young age and increasing the risk of obesity and related illnesses in later life.

Obesity and overweight are linked to at least 13 different types of cancer, as well as type 2 diabetes, heart disease and other conditions that affect healthy ageing.

At the start of primary school, 22.1 per cent of children in England are living with overweight or obesity, rising to 35.8 per cent by the time they leave. Children living with obesity are far more likely to live with obesity as adults.

Ashley Dalton, minister for health, said: “We promised to do everything we can to give every child the best and healthiest start in life.”

“By restricting adverts for junk food before 9pm and banning paid adverts online, we can remove excessive exposure to unhealthy foods – making the healthy choice the easy choice for parents and children.

“We’re moving the dial from having the NHS treat sickness, to preventing it so people can lead healthier lives and so it can be there for us when we need it.”

Colette Marshall, chief executive at Diabetes UK, said:

“With type 2 diabetes on the rise in young people, the need to improve children’s health in the UK has never been greater.

“Obesity is a major risk factor for type 2 diabetes, and the condition can lead to more severe consequences in young people – leaving them at risk of serious complications like kidney failure and heart disease.

“The long-awaited move to restrict junk food advertising – along with other measures such as mandatory healthy food sales reporting for businesses and the extension of the Soft Drinks Industry Levy – can help protect the health of our children, creating a future where conditions like type 2 diabetes can be prevented in young people.”

The measures form part of a broader government approach to prevention, including extending the Soft Drinks Industry Levy to cover more products such as sugary milk-based drinks, and a ban on the sale of high-caffeine energy drinks to under-16s.

Continue Reading

Trending

Agetech World